- cross-posted to:
- news@lemmy.world
- cross-posted to:
- news@lemmy.world
You must log in or register to comment.
it’s unbelievably frustrating because Israel and the IDF could have tried being a hell of a lot more surgical about the whole thing, and at least tried to avoid becoming irreversibly hated by all Palestinians as well as saving more lives… but it’s becoming apparent that saving lives (hostages or civilians) was never really part of the plan.
The plan was lebensraum.
Unfortunately the plan of the Israeli regime has always been Lebensraum since 1948
We can say that both side don’t care about each other. It’s just that one side has all the weapon.
News just came out that the IDF killed 3 Israeli hostages. They killed 3 unarmed hostages that were Jewish… how can we expect them to care about anyone else?
Hint: they don’t
I’m certain that they didn’t mean to kill the three Jewish hostages. However, the fact that they went in guns blazing without a care to whether or not the people they were shooting were innocent or not… well, that’s sadly very telling
Exactly. I wouldn’t feel safe around the IDF regardless of what my status would be.
You mean genocide pushes people to the brink?
It’s almost like blood feuds don’t work as a means to de-escalate a conflict. shockedpikachuface An eye for an eye leaves everyone blind…
All the money Israel spends fighting Palestine could instead be spent making it a nice place to live.
'Course, the MIC wouldn’t like that.
'Course, the MIC wouldn’t like that.
they wouldn’t, would they?
Bomb a disproportionately large amount of civilians and children and Hamas support rises…shocking
It kinda is. I can’t imagine cheering for the guys who attracts the bombs my way.
Not sure how old you are, but I remember after 9/11 everyone being super mad about our foreign policy decisions since the 1940s and not happily giving up a massive amount of freedom and privacy to feel safer.
Actually, we forgot all our internal divisions, voted almost unanimously to give up those freedoms and and happily marched to 20 years of war.
The Palestinians are doing the same. They’re scared, so their turning to those in authority to protect them. Just like we did in America when we got scared.
Idk if the we is meant to include yourself, but anyone who happily supported the invasions after 2001 was an idiot. I was pretty young when 9/11 happened but even through the fear my family was smart enough to not blindly follow their emotions and the incessant “support the troops or else” narrative at the time.
It’s almost like living in a world where food, water, electricity, and aid are extremely scarce because your occupier wants them to be, while being in a constant state of displacement and fear from unending indiscriminate bombing campaigns that target schools, hospitals, refugee camps, and more can make some people act irrationally
It’s easy to cheer for the guys who are fighting the guy bombing you. And keeping you in inhumane conditions where, well…, I hope I don’t need to explain how life in Gaza is even in the best of days, but anyway the Israel disengagement came with the unsaid stipulation that Gaza would never be allowed to have a future. It’s natural to cheer for the people who are trying to change that.
Pretty sure Hamas, as a political entity, isn’t going to exist to reap the benefits of this newfound popularity
Hamas, any infrastructure supporting their terrorism, and any funding they move through partner nations all will cease to be within the next few months.
Gazans should focus on a party that actually gives a shit about them, going forward. Abbas is incompetent and corrupt, so perhaps they can get some new voices in politics.
If hamas stops existing another will take its place.
Terrorism does not work the same way as states do. Its a hydra.
The only way to solve this is to end the reason why it exists in the first place. Give palestinians a viable state, stop with the settlements, allow international supervision.
If people have a job, safety, food on their plate, they tend to not be terrorists.
If hamas stops existing another will take its place.
That’s one possibility,. not a guarantee
If people have a job, safety, food on their plate, they tend to not be terrorists.
Glad you agree with me about Gazan’s future tho
It’s not a guarantee that a power vacuum in an unstable state will result in another dictatorial religious-authoritarian terrorist group inserting itself into said power vacuum in a middle eastern undeveloped area?
As long as you don’t count an occurrence rate of 100% to be a guarantee, then sure.
This is why I think that Israel shouldn’t allow a power vacuum. “You break it, you fix it,” and this war has broken quite a lot.
Israel shouldn’t do a lot of things, it’s doubtful they’ll attempt to fix that. They’d rather the terrorists keep coming back, they love to kill Muslims just as much as Muslims love killing them. The two groups are both children that are constantly trying to get their big brothers into a global war over their ancient goat herder god beliefs.
Glad you agree with me about Gazan’s future tho
If Hamas loses, then we are looking at a second West bank.
Inshallah.
I would agree. People pick the rulers that benefit them most. Hamas/other terror groups may not be the best for human rights but they haven’t been bombing everything in Palestine for the last month. I think about the USA war on terror, they “defeated” Al Queda and simultaneously caused the rise of ISIS.
It’s even more interesting: the rise of ISIS was to a large extent propelled by Al-Qaeda and ex-Iraqi military being emprisioned together in Iraq by the US when it occupied it.
Through their own use of force against Iraqis simply for doing their job in the Iraqi State, the US as an occupying power created an even worse beast than the one they put down, because doing it led them to cooperate with Al-Qaeda.
It has huge parallels with Israel as an occupying power in Palestine using unrestrained violence against people for simply being Palestinians and should inform us of just how unlikely this is to lead to the end of Hamas-like groups there.
Gazans should focus on a party that actually gives a shit about them
Let’s assume such a party exists. What do you think they can do?
Not steal aid from Gazans and use it to fund their jihad.
Not corrupt Gazan schools.
Not run a theocratic state.
Not have the destruction of Israel as their sole goal
Normalize relations with Israel, Egypt, and Jordan
Not kidnap, torture, and kill dissidents
Build any sort of infrastructure with the money they’re given
Things like that
And how productive do you think this will be Israel intentionally keeps Gaza’s economy on the brink of collapse (by their own words).
The blockade only existed due to Hamas seizing power.
Hamas seized power because Palestinians know what “Israel” would do if they elected a peaceful government.
Yes - give them their own country for the first time in human history.
No, it won’t give them back some of their stolen land, but settlements will start probing up, and armed raids followed by murders and mass arrests will become commonplace.
No, it started 3 months before the elections. It was tightened after the Battle of Gaza.
Half of these are valid for Israel - funny isn’t it?
Which ones? Israel isn’t a theocracy. Israel has secular and private schools just like all free countries. Israel doesn’t steal from their people. 10/7 happened because Israel is normalizing relations, and did not succeed in ending that process, etc.
Sorry, but israel is a theocracy.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_Law:_Israel_as_the_Nation-State_of_the_Jewish_People
You either see jewish people as a religion or a race. Therefore the state is either theocratic or, well, racist.
It’s literally a secular state lol.
Islam is the second-largest religion in Israeli and Israeli Muslims have full rights and representation in government.
Israel is the “official state of the Jewish people” but not only a state for the Jewish people. It’s just the one that reliably won’t exterminate them.
If i said: South Africa is the official state of the white people. How would you feel about it?
Yeah, and Hamas wasn’t supposed to be able to attack Israel the way it did… and yet…
Yep sometimes terrorists succeed. See also, 9/11.
So you’re talking nonsense.
I’m sorry do you think the terrorists did not succeed on 9/11?
Or do you perhaps think Hamas is going to exist, as a political entity, after this war? Because I assure you that Israel is quite committed to making sure that doesn’t happen.
Israel is only committed to genocide, they are the ones that made Hamas what is today.
Strong disagree.
Oh no!
This is the best summary I could come up with:
RAMALLAH, West Bank (AP) — A wartime opinion poll among Palestinians published Wednesday shows a rise in support for Hamas, which appears to have ticked up even in the devastated Gaza Strip, and an overwhelming rejection of Western-backed President Mahmoud Abbas, with nearly 90% saying he must resign.
The findings by a Palestinian pollster signal more difficulties ahead for the Biden administration’s postwar vision for Gaza and raise questions about Israel’s stated goal of ending Hamas’ military and governing capabilities.
With survey results indicating a further erosion of the PA’s legitimacy, at a time when there’s no apparent path toward restarting credible negotiations on Palestinian statehood, the default for postwar Gaza is an open-ended Israeli occupation, pollster Khalil Shikaki said.
The videos, along with extensive eyewitness testimony and reporting by The Associated Press and others, show that hundreds of civilians in southern Israel, including women and children, were abducted or gunned down inside their own homes.
Shikaki said the most popular politician remains Marwan Barghouti, a prominent figure in Abbas’ Fatah movement who is serving multiple life terms in an Israeli prison for his alleged role in several deadly attacks during the second Palestinian uprising two decades ago.
Netanyahu has attacked Abbas for years, alleging he was enabling anti-Israeli incitement in the West Bank, while at the same time permitting regular Qatari support payments to Gaza that strengthened Hamas.
The original article contains 1,007 words, the summary contains 229 words. Saved 77%. I’m a bot and I’m open source!
Mamma Mia!
Pretty stupid, but okay
completely predictable and understandable to support the rebel group fighting the regime brutally occupying your country. People generally aren’t on board with just laying down and being genocided
Supporting the terrorist group that brought this over them is pretty stupid.
And let’s be clear here. They are terrorists, not rebels.
Supporting the terrorist group that brought this over them is pretty stupid
yeah humans aren’t rational actors, but they are predictable. The support of hamas is predictable due to the brutal apartheid
And let’s be clear here. They are terrorists, not rebels.
Terrorism is a tactic. Rebels are defined by who is fighting who. Hamas is a terrorist rebel group
You conveniently left the part out where they are also terrorists.
Also I wouldn’t call them rebels as they aren’t rebelling again their government, which would be Hamas, but against a foreign power.
IDF are also terrorists, so it seems like terrorists fighting each other?
I guess its time to stop differentiating between Hamas and Palestinians.
Funny you think they ever differentiated. Issac Herzog, the President of Israel explicitly said “there are no civilians” in Gaza. There have been plenty of called to “erase” Gaza and other genocidal rhetoric much of which has been implemented.
https://twitter.com/againstwarvoice/status/1735246580276506970
