Biting freeze peach commentary! So deep!

Now here’s a question… / scatterbrained thinking

In that priest arrested community on here, Catholics get shit on for pedophilia all the time. Speaking truth to power probably, defending kids.

And for sure this other comic the extremist made is real dicey (NSFW).

How do I square that (the stupidity of caring about the tunnel stuff) with the fact Metzitzah B’peh is just… whatever, I won’t tell you what to think about it. Factually, it’s controversial. Does it make sense to meme something you don’t like if it’s pro-kid but offensive to a marginalized group?

Source, which also talks about acceptance & rejection of using a glass tube so you don’t have to put your mouth on a baby’s bleeding penis.

Concise question: could an egalitarian draw a comic calling out Metzitzah B’peh as wrong without the comic being antisemitic?

Seeking comments from people who aren’t brain dead (aren’t antisemitic). (sry 2 many unclear words)

  • brbposting@sh.itjust.worksOP
    0·
    4 months ago

    Hoping to satisfy curiosity and clear up cognitive business!

    Religious freedom/Jewish people good

    Extremism bad

    Mouth on baby wound uncomfortable

    Criticism of uncomfortable acts good

    Extremist criticism of rare aspect of religion: explained as bad by top commenter, due to heavy handedness / lack of nuance

    = Comic not justified

    Not surprised you assume the worse though given this is the Internet! Healthy skepticism :)

    • TherouxSonfeir@lemm.ee
      0·
      4 months ago

      Uh huh…

      I think the intent is the part that makes this particular comic inappropriate. It’s not to point out that various religions or cultural groups have archaic rituals that are taboo or unsanitary. It’s to mock the Jews. If a comic included various religious practices, suggesting that all of them are out of place in modern society, it might have been okay. But this person specifically does it do be offensive, and appeal to people who enjoy inflicting pain.

      • brbposting@sh.itjust.worksOP
        0·
        4 months ago

        But this person specifically does it do be offensive, and appeal to people who enjoy inflicting pain.

        Some people like giving and receiving compliments, hugs, and well wishes. Meanwhile there’s this friggin’ guy. Can you imagine?

        If a comic included various religious practices, suggesting that all of them are out of place in modern society, it might have been okay.

        New antisemitic strategy unlocked! I kid.

        Something for me to think about, thanks :)