I got some random selection of Bookmarks suddenly lost from Firefox Bookmark Folders, some Folders entirely cleared… I’m I the only one?!

  • mlemiputty@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    I tried searching for anyone else with this issue a month and a half ago, because this happened to me. The bookmarks I lost were not all nested, and I’ve notice this happen in windows 11 (all exploit protection disabled), and debian 12(both OS different browser profile) I wondered if maybe using the ‘Exit’ in menu instead of X/middle click tab to close might be related, but I don’t know any code evidence in recent releases to corroborate this. This issue was first recognized for me about 2-3 firefox versions ago. 32gb ram i9 9th gen, I use privacy badger, privacy possum, adguard with most filters enabled, decentraleyes, and user agent switcher. I always run in private browsing. I don’t think this is related to a malicious website.

    I do not have any sync agents like firefox sync enabled. One instance has about 50~ bookmarks with 3 folders no subfolders, one instance has about 500 with many subfolders.

    I assume only recently added bookmarks have disappeared, but I have no way to verify and my memory wasn’t perfect.

    • 乇ㄥ乇¢ㄒ尺ㄖ@infosec.pubOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      This issue was first recognized for me about 2-3 firefox versions ago

      It’s weird, first time something like this happened to me, I’m on Fedora ( FF v124.0.1 ) and I don’t think it has anything to do with how you close windows, I was organizing my bookmarks I checked Lemmy for a second, went back at it again, to see that my work gone… I didn’t touch anything…

      The only thing that I think caused it is FF Sync, because it keeps running in the background… But you don’t use it, which is why I said it’s weird…

      One instance has about 50~ bookmarks with 3 folders no subfolders, one instance has about 500 with many subfolders… I assume only recently added bookmarks have disappeared, but I have no way to verify and my memory wasn’t perfect

      My bookmarks were there for more than a year, they didn’t vanish until I started moving them around, so I guess there’s a bug that affects large folders

      Tab Stash Bookmarks aren’t affected…

      I use privacy badger, privacy possum, adguard with most filters enabled, decentraleyes, and user agent switcher.

      Unrelated but why all these ? you can reap better results ( reduced attack surface, better fingerprinting protection ) with different extensions,

      Ublock and enable : Adguard URL tracking protection

      Firefox Containers : Isolates websites/activies from each other

      Cookies ( Privacy Badger ) : FF has Total Cookie Protection since v86, you just need to set the protection level to Strict mode

      Fingerprinting ( Privacy Possum, UAS ), redundant with RF ( resist fingerprinting ) feature, go to about config, and search for privacy.resist fingerprinting > enable it

      decentraleyes : redundant with Total Cookie Protection

      The only two you need really, is Unlock and Canvas Blocker ( if you’re not going to use Arkenfox ), FF containers

      Edit : sorry, three…lol